Thursday, September 27, 2018

Dogs and Eco-Trauma: The Making of a Monster in White God Part I




After adopting several rescue dogs, all of whom suffered abuse and neglect, it comes as 
no surprise to us that both human and nonhuman animals may suffer the consequences 
of eco-trauma. As part of human society, dogs may also be traumatized by a toxic 
environment. As cultural critic David R. Shumway asserts, “pets … ought to be 
understood as elements of a healthy human society” (272). According to Shumway, 
“if humans have typically lived in a mixed community with animals, then our definition 
of ‘society’ should be expanded to reflect the fact that not all of the subjects to whom 
we relate are human” (272). As noted ecocritic Anil Narine suggests, “a traumatized
earth begets traumatized people” (13), but a traumatized earth may also negatively affect 
other species. 



Films highlighting dogfighting reveal much about the complex connections between 
humans and their dogs. In this presentation, we argue that by exposing the abuse dogs 
endure during cruel training for and violent assaults in the dogfight ring, the fictional 
film White God(2015) powerfully demonstrates the repercussions of mistreatment in 
a toxic environment: eco-trauma. But it also offers a solution: love.



White God suggests a traumatized earth may also traumatize the pets we love, especially 
in an urban setting. The opening of White Godhighlights the consequences of such 
environmental trauma. A long shot reveals a starkly empty silent Budapest street where 
thirteen-year-old Lili (Zsófia Psotta) rides her bike across a deserted bridge. The music 
is quiet as she passes an abandoned car and bus, suggesting a forced escape for their 
passengers. Cutting to a city street as she continues to bike, an enormous pack of dogs 
runs up behind and past her, as if responding to the trumpet in her backpack. This 
opening scene ends with a flashback to Lili playing with her dog Hagen to underpin 
the dramatic change trauma has produced in this once happy house pet.



When her mother leaves for three months to Australia, Lili and Hagen’s lives are disrupted 
when they are forced to move in with Lili’s meat inspector father Daniel (Sándor Zsótér), 
who lives in a small and insular apartment building. In this traumatic ecology, a neighbor 
(Erika Bodnár) reports illegal mixed breed ownership to authorities, claiming Hagen bit 
her. Canine officers warn Lili and her father they must pay a heavy state tax and register 
the mixed breed or lose him. Forced to sleep in a closed bathroom, Hagen howls. Only 
Lili’s trumpet can calm him. When Lili sneaks Hagen into her band rehearsal and disturbs 
the practice, her director throws them out. In retaliation, Lili’s father casts Hagen out of 
their car in the middle of a crowded avenue and drives off. His actions catalyze the series 
of traumatic experiences that nearly condemn Hagen to death. 



Ultimately, White God illustrates the similarities between humans and dogs. 
Both species respond positively to love, and negatively to cruelty. 
In White God,the hope is that love may counter the environmental trauma humanity creates.

No comments:

Post a Comment